A Tongue So Sweet and Deadly
Audiobook & Ebook

A Tongue So Sweet and Deadly by Sophia St. Germain | Audiobook Review

Part of The Compelling Fates Saga #1

By Sophia St. Germain

Narrated by Abigail Reno

🎧 13 hours and 57 minutes 📘 Podium Audio 📅 June 17, 2025 🌐 English

About This Audiobook

Half-Fae Elessia could have had everything. Literally.

Since her magic allows her to compel anyone to do her bidding by merely looking into their eyes, the world was at her feet. But after a tragic accident, she is thrown into the Fae king's dungeons and forced to swear a blood oath to him, binding her to his service.

Five years later, she's living amongst humans in Ellow and has created a life for herself - as much as she can with the king's promise to call in his debt looming over her.

When he finally comes to collect, she is made to infiltrate the human elections to determine whether the current regent is involved in the strange things happening in the land of Fae.

With the promise of freedom from the king's claws, Elessia is determined to see it through. Liberty is within reach as long as she can keep the lethal Fae guard watching over her from eliminating her before she unearths the information the king seeks.

But as she grows closer to the brooding human regent and secrets begin to unravel, Elessia realizes greater forces may be at play. And she might stand before the choice between her own freedom and that of a nation.

Contains mature content. A complete list of content warnings can be found on the author's website.

🎧 Listen Free on Audible

Free 30-day trial · Cancel anytime

  • Read by: Abigail Reno takes a Fae king, a lethal guard, a human regent and a compulsion-wielding narrator through nearly fourteen hours in one voice.
  • At its heart: Blood oaths and bound service, compulsion magic, political infiltration, enemies to lovers.
  • Vibe: Twisty and plot-forward, with the romance kept on a short leash.
  • Short version: Strong series fantasy for anyone content with a split that favors the intrigue over the couple.

Elessia can compel anyone who meets her eyes to do whatever she wants, which is the sort of power a fantasy romance usually withholds until the final act, and this audiobook gives it away in the opening line of its description. Then it takes the power back. A tragic accident puts her in the Fae king's dungeons, a blood oath binds her to his service, and five years later she is living among humans in a town called Ellow, waiting for the debt to be called in. Fourteen hours of consequences follow from that.

Podium Audio has put one reader, Abigail Reno, on thirteen hours and fifty-seven minutes of court intrigue, warring kingdoms, a Fae guard, a human regent and a national election. That is a substantial cast for a single voice, and the credit is the only performance information the listing offers. What it does establish is scale: a first volume running close to fourteen hours belongs to a series that intends to take its time. The page marks it book one of The Compelling Fates Saga, and one response is already through it and into the next.

A 4.3 badge rests on seventeen votes, and the five responses beneath it spread out unusually well: two fives, two fours and a three. That distribution is worth more than a wall of enthusiasm would be, because the dissent arrives specific. Amalie describes being cancel-my-plans hooked and reading faster through the final tenth of the book. Emma Whiting, at four stars, manages to call it entertaining and not a literary masterpiece inside the same paragraph. W.N.C.M.Sanchez, at three, never finished it, returned it, and blames a style thick with run-on sentences. All three are describing the same book accurately.

Emma Whiting supplies the single most useful line anywhere on the page: roughly seventy percent plot to thirty percent romance, a few spicy scenes, and a book far more concerned with magic and political intrigue than with the couple. Anyone shopping the romance shelf should weigh that before buying, because it marks the difference between a romance in a fantasy setting and a fantasy with a romance running underneath it. The four-star entry signed Amazon Customer maps the same balance from the other side, listing human, fae and shifters, a king's spy, warring kingdoms, trials, secrets, betrayal, hidden identities and, memorably, only one horse.

The Strengths

Abigail Reno's job here is harder than the runtime alone suggests. A first-person narrator whose magic works through eye contact spends the book watching people, and compulsion scenes only land if a listener can hear the difference between choosing to use the power and choosing to hold it back. Add a Fae king, a lethal guard posted to watch her, and a brooding human regent, all delivered in one voice across fourteen hours, and the performance is carrying most of the differentiation that a printed page would handle with white space and dialogue tags.

Fourteen hours also says something about pacing, and the responses confirm it from both directions. Indomexican0304 describes twists and turns sustaining attention throughout, with characters revealed in layers as the history behind each one surfaces. W.N.C.M.Sanchez found the opening not especially interesting and continued only to see whether it improved. A book this long that saves its best reversals for the end is asking for patience at the front, and whether you have that patience is a question the sample settles faster than any written response can.

Several entries point at the same structural spine, which is rare enough to be worth trusting. The setup is a spy plot: someone bound by an oath is sent to infiltrate an election and establish whether the current regent is mixed up in the strange things happening in the land of Fae. Political intrigue gets named independently by two responses. Enemies to lovers gets named by a third, with a question mark attached to it. The description supplies the stake, one person's freedom weighed against the fate of a nation, and that is where this first volume is pointed.

Before You Commit to A Tongue So Sweet and Deadly

Content warnings are the thing this listing handles worst. The description confirms mature content and then states that a complete list of content warnings can be found on the author's website, which means the information exists and has been placed somewhere other than here. A listener who needs it must leave the page, find the site and locate the list before deciding whether to spend fourteen hours in this world. The only intensity signal on the page itself is that phrase about a few spicy scenes, sitting inside an entry chiefly concerned with politics. For a category whose range runs from a closed door to something considerably further along, that is thin.

Two smaller inconsistencies deserve flagging. One of the most enthusiastic responses calls the protagonist Lessia while the description calls her Elessia, so anyone searching for the character by name will meet two spellings and no way to tell from this page which the book uses. The trope-listing entry also carries a mid-sentence typo that no listener will ever encounter, since audio quietly repairs that class of error. Neither affects the recording. Both affect how much weight a written column deserves when the format under discussion is a performance.

Recommended For

Romantasy readers who want the fantasy half taken seriously are the clearest fit, and that seventy-thirty estimate is the number to plan around. Anyone who enjoys a competence plot, an infiltration, an oath with a countdown attached to it, will get more from this than someone waiting on the couple to arrive. Series bingers are well served too: the first volume evidently ends in a way that sends people onward, and one response documents making that jump without pausing.

Steer clear if prose quality is the thing you cannot forgive, since two of the five responses raise it independently, one calling the writing just okay and the other abandoning the book over run-on sentences. Steer clear as well if you need content warnings visible before committing, because these have been parked on a website. Everyone else gets a long, twisty series opener that knows exactly what it is: political fantasy with a romance threaded through it. Reno carries fourteen hours of that alone, and the credit is the whole of what this page will tell you about the listening.

Good to Know

How explicit is this audiobook, and where are the content warnings?

The description confirms mature content and then sends you to the author's website for the complete list, so the guidance exists but not on this page. The only on-page signal comes from a four-star entry mentioning a few spicy scenes while stressing how much more of the book is politics.

Is this more romance or more fantasy?

More fantasy, by the account of the most specific response on the page, which puts the split at roughly seventy percent plot to thirty percent romance and calls the book mainly a story about magic and political intrigue. A second entry lists warring kingdoms and hidden identities before it mentions the couple.

How long is the audiobook and who reads it?

Thirteen hours and fifty-seven minutes, with Abigail Reno alone in the credits. One reader handles a Fae king, a guard posted to kill if ordered, a brooding human regent, and a protagonist who compels people by catching their eye. That is a wide range for one voice.

Ready to listen?

🎧 Listen to A Tongue So Sweet and Deadly for free

Free 30-day trial · Cancel anytime

What Listeners Are Saying

★★★★★

Twisted and Addictive

I picked up A Tongue So Sweet and Deadly thinking I’d get a fun fantasy romance to pass the time - and instead I got hooked. Like, cancel-my-plans hooked. By the last 10% I was literally reading faster because I needed to know how everything was going to collide.Lessia is...

- Amalie
★★★★☆

Fun Read

As a voracious Romantasy reader, this book was pretty entertaining but isn't a literary masterpiece by any means. The story is compelling and has unexpected plot twists! The writing was just okay, in my opinion, but the author does a good job of story telling for anyone looking for a...

- Emma Whiting
★★★★★

loved it!

I enjoyed this book so much!! It was full of twists and turns that kept me interested the whole time. I liked the element of mystery that wove its ways into the greater plot. The twists at the end I did not see coming, and I am just so excited...

- Indomexican0304
★★★★☆

fantastic fantasy read!!

This was a wonderful fantasy reqd . There was character growth with out FMC and there were twists and turns everywhere!🐍human, fae , shifters❤️kings spy🐍warring kingdoms❤️trials and tests🐍secrets and betrayal❤️hidden identities🐍only one horse❤️enemies to lovers to ?🐍political intrigue

- Amazon Customer
★★★☆☆

Not my favorite

My honest opinion is I didn’t love it. I actually didn’t finish. It wasn’t super interesting from the start, but I tried to keep going to see if it got better. I personally don’t love the writing style and I noticed there were many run-on sentences which annoys me for...

- W.N.C.M.Sanchez

Free Listening

Listen to the Audiobook for Free: A Tongue So Sweet and Deadly

  • ✓ Audible: 30-day free trial, your first audiobook free
  • ✓ Cancel anytime in one click
Alexandra Reed

Written by Alexandra Reed

Founder & Literary Critic